DiCarlo's Pizza - Glendale is a delightful gem located at 1720 Wheeling Ave, Glen Dale, WV. This pizza parlor has carved its niche in the local food scene, capturing hearts with its unique take on pizza—cooked crust topped with fresh ingredients. Customers like Spythug007 rave about their experiences, noting the friendly service and the enticing aromas wafting from the pizza boxes. The walls adorned with historical newspaper articles add a charming touch, enhancing the overall dining atmosphere. While the topping selection may seem limited at first glance, patrons have expressed satisfaction with the quality and freshness of the ingredients. The crispy crust remains a standout; Demi Koulis emphasizes how consistently fresh and well-prepared the pizzas are. Moreover, the pepperoni rolls—stuffed with cheese and pepperoni—are considered a must-try, promising a satisfying snack. However, a few reviews mention mild frustrations with online ordering accuracy, where requested extras like cheese and pepper are occasionally overlooked. Despite this, the general consensus is that DiCarlo's embodies a true Ohio Valley experience, one that combines nostalgia with great flavor. Megan Loy encapsulates the sentiment perfectly, calling it a "must-stop" for anyone in the area. If you’re seeking delicious, hearty pizza in a cozy setting, DiCarlo's Pizza - Glendale should definitely be on your list.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Highlights
Has fast service
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy
Crowd
Popular with tourists
Popular with university students
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For DiCarlo's Pizza - Glendale
Spythug007
May 29,2025
I had never eaten here before! It was amazing! Upon entry to the store, I was greeted promptly, and my order was taken. I was slightly taken aback at the lack of toppings offered, but nonetheless, we ordered a tray to go. I received my order a little faster than I anticipated, but I did have some time to take in my surroundings. There were a lot of cool things going on here, mostly newspaper articles from previous decades, but I love history! It was so interesting to see the beginnings to present day all over the walls! After leaving the store, I could not believe the amazing aroma that came from that pizza box. I wanted to open that box then and there! Highly recommended!
Pauline Leasure
May 29,2025
Pretty cool way to serve pizza, cooked crust then add the toppings and close the pizza to go box and let the heat from the crust melt it all together.
Haley M
Apr 17,2025
Not bad at all. Only complaint is they frequently forget to include sides such as bags of cheese, bags of peppers, etc. Online ordering could be streamlined as there is no option to order only cheese. I've just been changing my name no "No Pepperoni" and it works every time.
Megan Loy
Apr 3,2025
Fantastic as always! A true Ohio Valley staple! Great food and service! A must stop when in the area!
Demi Koulis
Mar 25,2025
Best DiCarlos in the area imo, pizza is always crispy and fresh. Staff is very friendly and the order was done on the amount of time they said. I wanted to try to the pepperoni roll, but the tray was enough for me and the people I ordered it for. I was really impressed with the lunch combo they offered with the included drink. The price was right and if I was in the area permanently this would definitely be one of my go to lunch spots. It always nice to go back home and experience good food, I can't say enough good things about this particular location!
Jason Karpiel
Mar 3,2025
This is a classic spot and a must when you are in the area. One place I always order from no matter how long I am in town for. I love the pizza and it OSS one of the few that can be heated in your oven the next day and still have that crispy flaky crust and taste just as good as it did when it’s fresh.
Brian Martin
Feb 10,2025
I love this style of pizza. My wife said it was the best Dicarlos pizza she'd had. The crust was perfectly done. They have a couple of tables so you can eat it immediately out of the oven.
Julia B
Feb 8,2025
This Di Carlo's pizza is on the ball. It is the best tasting. Di Carlos... I have one that is 5 minutes for me in downtown Wheeling yet I go 25 minutes to Glendale to get their pizza.
Reviews For DiCarlo's Pizza - Glendale